Warner Bros. Pictures via Everett Collection
With only a week and change having passed since the release of The Amazing Spider-Man 2, we no doubt feel the question living fresh in our minds: can we ever judge a remake without considering its predecessors? The conversation about the stark contrast in critical favor between Marc Webb's release and Sam Raimi's trilogy (the second installment of his franchise in particular) buzzed loudly, and we imagine the volume will keep in regards to Gareth Edwards' Godzilla. But it'll be a different sound altogether.
The original Godzilla, a Japanese film released in 1954, reinvented the identity of the monster movie, launched a 30-film legacy, and spoke legions about the political climate of its era. The most recent of these films — Roland Emmerich's 1998 American production — is universally bemoaned as a bigger disaster than anything to befall Tokyo at the hands of the giant reptile. With these two entries likely standing out as the most prominent in the minds of contemporary audiences, Edwards' Godzilla has some long shadows cast before it. And in approaching the new movie, one might not be able to avoid comparisons to either. It's fair — by taking on an existing property, a filmmaker knowingly takes on the connotations of that property. But the 2014 installment's great success is that it isn't much like any Godzilla movie we've seen before. In a great, great way.
This isn't 1954's Godzilla, a dire and occasionally dreary allegory that uses the supernatural to tell an important story about nuclear holocaust. A complete reversal, in fact, first and foremost Edwards' Godzilla is about its monsters. Any grand themes strewn throughout — the perseverence of nature, the follies of mankind, fatherhood, madness, faith — are all in service to the very simple mission to give us some cool, weighty, articulate sci-fi disaster. Elements of gravity are plotted all over the film's surface, with scientists, military men (kudos to Edwards for not going the typical "scientists = good/smart, military = bad/dumb" route in this film — everybody here is at least open to suggestion), doctors, police officers, and a compassionate bus driver all wrestling with options in the face of behemoth danger. The humanity is everpresent, but never especially intrusive. To reiterate, this isn't a film about any of these people, or what they do.
Warner Bros. Pictures via Everett Collection
The closest thing to a helping of thematic (or human) significance comes with Ken Watanabe's Dr. Serizawa, who spouts awe-stricken maxims about cryptozoology, the Earth, and the inevitable powerlessness of man. He might not be supplying anything more substantial than our central heroes (soft-hearted soldier Aaron Taylor-Johnson, dutiful medic and mom Elizabeth Olsen, right-all-along conspiracy theorist Bryan Cranston), but Watanabe's bonkers performance as the harried scientist is so bizarrely good that you might actually believe, for a scene or two, that it all does mean something.
Ultimately, the beauty of our latest taste of Godzilla lies not in the commitment to a message that made the original so important nor in the commitment to levity that made Emmerich's so pointless, but in its commitment to imagination. Edwards' creature design is dazzling, his deus ex machina are riveting, and the ultimate payoff to which he treats his audience is the sort of gangbusters crowd-pleaser that your average contemporary monster movie is too afraid to consider.
In fairness, this year's Godzilla might not be considered an adequate remake, not quite reciprocating the ideals, tone, or importance of the original. Sure, anyone looking for a 2014 answer to 1954's game-changing paragon will find sincere philosophy traded for pulsing adventure... but they'd have a hard time ignoring the emphatic charm of this new lens for the 60-year-old lizard, both a highly original composition and a tribute in its way to the very history of monster movies (a history that owes so much to the creature in question). So does Godzilla '14 successfully fill the shoes of Godzilla '54? No — it rips them apart and dons a totally new pair... though it still has a lot of nice things to say about the first kicks.
Oh, and the '98 Godzilla? Yeah, it's better than that.
Follow @Michael Arbeiter| Follow @Hollywood_com
Top Story: Foley Says Infidelity Didn't Cause Split
Scott Foley is quelling rumors that his split with wife Jennifer Garner was due to infidelity, The Associated Press reports. "Nobody else was involved," Foley says in TV Guide's Oct. 25 issue. "Jennifer became a huge celebrity. She became a huge star, and she deserved everything she got. There was no other relationship, there was no infidelity, nothing. People get divorced, you know? Through no one's fault and everyone's fault." The Alias star and Foley met in 1998 on the set of the WB show Felicity and married in October 2000.
John Ritter Remembered
About 1,000 people gathered Tuesday night at the El Capitan Theatre in Los Angeles to remember John Ritter, who died Sept. 11 at the age of 54 of an undetected heart problem, AP reports. Some of those who spoke included his wife, actress Amy Yasbeck, his 8 Simple Rules co-star Katey Sagal and Michael Eisner, the head of Walt Disney Co., which owns ABC. Ritter's close friend, director Peter Bogdanovich, described the actor as "loving, funny, warmhearted, kind, generous, mischievous as a young kid, unpretentious."
Moore Supports Calif. Recall Election
During a forum at Butler University in Indianapolis, Ind., Oscar-winning documentary filmmaker Michael Moore told students the recent recall election in California proves democracy can work, AP reports. "Any time you have an angry mob of voters, that can't be a bad thing," Moore said to about 2,100 people Monday. The activist-filmmaker added he hoped voters would show the same sentiment to stop President Bush from getting a second term.
Gary Coleman's New Job
Gary Coleman, who lost to Arnold Schwarzenegger in the Calif. recall election last week, has accepted a post as a political analyst for the Hollywood-based All Comedy Radio, CNN.com reports. The 35-year-old former child star will be the network's political analyst and said his experience as a candidate will come in handy in this new assignment. Among the topics he'll tackle will be the 2004 presidential election.
The Dead Return to Sopranos
The whacked are back! According to The Hollywood Reporter, the upcoming season of The Sopranos will feature an episode in which the ghosts of Tony Soprano's past return, including Vincent Pastore (aka Salvatore "Big Pussy" Bonpensiero), David Proval (Richie Aprile), John Heard (Detective Vin Makazian), Al Sapienza (Mikey Palmice), Dan Grimaldi (Philly "Spoons" Parisi), Jason Cerbone (Jackie Aprile Jr.) and Joe Pantoliano (Ralph Cifaretto), who recently won an Emmy for his Sopranos performance.
Star Trek Captain Separates From Wife
Patrick Stewart, best known as Capt. Jean-Luc Picard of the Star Trek: The Next Generation series, has filed for a legal separation from his wife of three years. AP reports Stewart, 63, cited irreconcilable differences in the court papers filed Tuesday. He and Wendy Neuss-Stewart, who have no children, were married in August 2000.
Tickets to Cash Memorial Available by Lottery
Free tickets to the Nov. 10 Johnny Cash Memorial Tribute in Nashville, Tenn., will be available via a lottery, AP reports. Performers at the concert include John Mellencamp, Dwight Yoakam, George Jones, Willie Nelson, Kris Kristofferson, Sheryl Crow and Hank Williams Jr. Fans wanting tickets are advised to send a 3-1/2 by 5-inch card or paper with name, address and daytime telephone number to: Johnny Cash Memorial Tribute, P.O. Box 20003, Nashville, TN 37202. Only one entry per person is allowed, and all entries must be received by 11:59 p.m. ET Oct. 26, AP reports.
Role Call: Pirates Back for More, Cage Gets Into the Ring
Gore Verbinski has signed up to helm the sequel to his mega-hit Pirates of the Caribbean: The Curse of the Black Pearl. Variety reports Johnny Depp will also reprise his starring role as Capt. Jack Sparrow, while Disney had already made sequel arrangements with key players Orlando Bloom and Keira Knightley…Nicolas Cage is set to star in a yet-untitled biopic about a former boxing champion, Billy "The Kid" Roth, who ended up coaching hundreds of Louisiana prison inmates and acting as their surrogate father. According to The Hollywood Reporter, Cage's production company Saturn Films is developing the feature.