Burgi bounced back quickly when he starred as the lead on “The Sentinel” (UPN, 1995-1999), a supernatural procedural in which he played a police detective whose five senses were mystically heightened after surviving 18 months in the Peruvian jungle, helping him solve criminal cases in record time. The show managed to stick around for several seasons, but in 1998 the network threatened to axe the show. An Internet campaign organized by fans helped give “The Sentinel” another season, but UPN finally canceled the series in 1999. Burgi next starred in the made-for-TV movie, “I Married a Monster” (UPN, 1998), playing a groom who becomes possessed by an alien being intent on procreating its dying race through humans. After individual episodes of “Veronica’s Closet” (NBC, 1997-2000), “Just Shoot Me” (NBC, 1996-2003) and “CSI: Crime Scene Investigation” (CBS, 2000- ), Burgi was seen on several series in recurring roles, including “Judging Amy” (CBS, 1999-2005) as the judge’s bitter ex-husband, “The District” (CBS, 2000-2004) as the captain of Internal Affairs, and “24” (Fox, 2001- ) as the imposter of a man murdered after his daughter was kidnapped.
Burgi began appearing in more feature length projects, including the supernatural movie-of-the-week “Bailey’s Mistake” (ABC, 2001), about a woman (Linda Hamilton) and her two children living on a mysterious island after the death of her husband, and “Torn Apart” (Lifetime, 2004), in which he was the kidnapped husband of a doctor (Tia Carrere) forced to choose who will die—her husband or her daughter. In “Starship Troopers 2” (Starz!, 2004), he played a disillusioned captain of the Mobile Infantry who is unapologetic about killing his commander. Then after supporting roles in “Decoys” (Sci-Fi, 2004), a horror-comedy about two voluptuous coeds suspected of a series of on-campus murders, and “Darklight” (2004), about a captured demoness recruited to destroy a monster about to unleash a deadly worldwide plague, Burgi made the jump to features, starting with a small part in the action thriller “Cellular” (2004). He then appeared in the comedy “In Her Shoes” (2005) as the prospective boyfriend for a Princeton-educated attorney (Toni Collette) with low-self esteem about her appearance.
Burgi next appeared in “Desperate Housewives” (ABC, 2004- ) as the roguish ex-husband of Susan (Teri Hatcher), a role he reveled in because it allowed him to display his more mischievous side. At first, the part was recurring, but he became a member of the regular cast for the second season. Meanwhile, Burgi continued making features—he appeared in “Fun With Dick and Jane” (2005) as the smug Yuppie neighbor of a couple (Jim Carrey and Tea Leoni) forced to go on a robbing spree in order to save their well-to-do lifestyle.