After "The Brothers McMullen", he co-starred as Oliver Barnett, a teammate of "Ed", an unsuccessful 1996 spring comedy starring Matt LeBlanc. McGlone reteamed with actor-writer-director Burns in "She's the One" (also 1996). In the latter, he was a smug Wall Street executive who cheats on his wife with his brother's ex-fiancee. The actor had his best role (to date) as a mobster who counts among his childhood friends a policeman in "One Tough Cop" (1998).