American Pie Stars: Then & Now

1
Tara Reid
Tara Reid
Jenny Dayco (Commentary)/ Hollywood.com
By looking at this early photo of Tara Reid, it is a surprise that no wardrobe malfunction appeared then. Now, she looks much more refined and ladylike in this gray, floral accented gown by Los Angeles based designer Christiane King.
2
Mena Suvari
Mena Suvari
Jenny Dayco (Commentary)/ Hollywood.com
Petite beauty Mena Suvari never fails to dazzle on the red carpet. In the first photo, she looks quietly chic in an all white outfit, and in the next photo, she turns up the volume with her printed tea length Alice + Olivia dress at the Australian premiere of 'American Reunion' on March 7th.
3
Alyson Hannigan
Alyson Hannigan
Jenny Dayco (Commentary)/ Hollywood.com
In 'American Pie', Alyson Hannigan's character was definitely a dominatrix in the making! But in 2001, she smiles sweetly in this yoga-inspired red carpet look. A couple weeks ago, Alyson proudly shows off her adorable belly-bump in this lovely dark green sequin dress. Alyson is currently expecting a second baby with her husband, actor Alexis Denisof.
article continues below ad
4
Eddie Kaye Thomas
Eddie Kaye Thomas
Jenny Dayco (Commentary)/ Hollywood.com
By looking at the first photo, who would ever guess that Eddie Kaye Thomas as Finch would pass as Stifler's mom's young lover? But, Eddie turns things around from "boy band look-a-like" at the September 2005 'Dirty Love' premiere, to fashionably handsome (sans Jew-fro!) in just a few years.
5
John Cho
John Cho
Jenny Dayco (Commentary)/ Hollywood.com
John Cho has certainly experienced a style evolution! At the 2006 MTV Movie Awards, John's look appears "collegiate-ly layered" and a touch ill-fitting. On March 19th, he dominates the red carpet with this sharply tailored blue suit. From MILF guy #2, to Harold the stoner, to the iconic Sulu in 'Star Trek', we will be seeing more of John in the future.
6
Seann William Scott
Seann William Scott
Jenny Dayco (Commentary)/ Hollywood.com
Who could forget Seann William Scott as Stifler as the film franchise's hunky douchebag? Never one to be red-flagged on the red carpet, Seann is just as stylish then as he is now, from a young Hollywood poster boy to a dapper gentleman — with his trademark bad-boy smirk!
article continues below ad
7
Jennifer Coolidge
Jennifer Coolidge
Jenny Dayco (Commentary)/ Hollywood.com
And speaking of Stifler, Jennifer Coolidge's unforgettable character as Stifler's mom popularized the term MILF. In both these photos, Jennifer clearly embodies her MILF status — perhaps a bit too much at her appearance at the 'American Reunion' premiere. Another cast member does not need a boob-slip on the red carpet!
8
Shannon ElizabethTara Reid
Shannon ElizabethTara Reid
Jenny Dayco (Commentary)/ Hollywood.com
And speaking of Stifler, Jennifer Coolidge's unforgettable character as Stifler's mom popularized the term MILF. In both these photos, Jennifer clearly embodies her MILF status — perhaps a bit too much at her appearance at the 'American Reunion' premiere. Another cast member does not need a boob-slip on the red carpet!
9
Jason Biggs
Jason Biggs
Jenny Dayco (Commentary)/ Hollywood.com
In the late 90's, 'American Pie' was the definitive coming-of-age sex comedy of the decade. Remember when Jason Biggs had sex with an apple pie? At the 'American Pie 2' premiere in 2001, Jason cleans up well in this handsome blue suit. Almost 11 years later, at the 'American Reunion' premiere in Berlin, Jason is still playful and goofy in this casual look.
article continues below ad
10
Thomas Ian Nicholas
Thomas Ian Nicholas
Jenny Dayco (Commentary)/ Hollywood.com
Thomas Ian Nicholas' style has definitely come a long way! At the 2006 premiere of 'American Dreamz', his overall look appears like he just rolled out of bed. In the recent photo, Thomas looks like a "haute hipster" with his 'stache, peacoat, cuffed jeans, and distressed boots.
11
Chris Klein
Chris Klein
Jenny Dayco (Commentary)/ Hollywood.com
Playing the part of the pretty-boy jock turned choir singer, Chris Klein was the perfect casting as Oz in the 'American Pie' franchise. In his real-life search for love, he was formerly engaged to (now A-List lady) Katie Holmes, and dated 'Once Upon A Time' star Ginnifer Goodwin. Within the span of 11 years, Chris is still heart-meltingly handsome as he wears both suits effortlessly.
12
Eugene Levy
Eugene Levy
Jenny Dayco (Commentary)/ Hollywood.com/Syndicated by: TNN
Of course, this photoset would not be complete without Eugene Levy, as the unforgettably awkward father of Jim (played by Jason Biggs) in the film's franchise. Eugene is always red-carpet ready with his signature round glasses and dark suits.

SIMILAR ARTICLES