By Nicholas White
Story
Black Christmas is a nihilistic evolution from the 1974 horror flick, in which a solo good guy or girl always survive. It is also an exceedingly gruesome, frenetic update of the original, with distributor Dimension mandating a second cut of the film after the first wasn't bloody enough, much to director
Glen Morgan’s chagrin. In 2006's version, a jaundiced, sickly boy Billy is born to an abusive household. He learns to hate Christmas when his alcoholic mother murders his father on the holiday. Predatory spirit lingers in the building 30 years later, now a refurbished sorority house. At least one killer is terrorizing the girls, who are snowed in for the holiday. Billy, meanwhile, is a killer Santa locked in a sanitarium across town and is pining to escape. The sorority girls soon run for their lives.
Acting
Surely, you're not expecting
The Departed--please, the bigger the horror caricature, the better.
Michelle Trachtenberg, as sorority sister Melissa, is as adorably nymphish as we remember from TV's
Buffy the Vampire Slayer. The 21-year-old actress, last seen in the
Chad Lowe indie
Beautiful Ohio, does her first horror film, and delivers several one-liners eligible for a Razzie Award. As disposable eye candy, 20-something actresses
Crystal Lowe and
Jessica Harmon have been elevated from extra status for their seeming acting
inability. Up-and-comer
Mary Elizabeth Winstead (
Bobby) sports her native North Carolina accent for presumed "Method" purposes, playing the good-hearted Southern simpleton as though she's on
Dawson's Creek. It's a good thing former
Dawson's star,
Oliver Hudson is here as the jerky Kyle, so unpredictable and malicious we don't know--or care frankly--if he's the killer or not. Why couldn't
Katie Holmes have done this film instead of becoming Mrs.
Tom Cruise?
Direction
Glen Morgan seems to be a troubled man. Besides his work with
Crispin Glover and an army of rats on
Willard,
Morgan has, with
Black Christmas, successfully captured a homicidal mother reproducing with her 13-year-old. It’s sick, more so even than the college cuties whose brains are splayed across the garbage bags used to suffocate them. Early death scenes have effective comic punctuation similar to the irreverent
Final Destination 3, which, incidentally,
Morgan co-wrote, produced and assistant-directed. But
Black Christmas unfortunately devolves into a dark and troubled mud puddle. Cohesion is scrapped for sleekness. The movie has a violent, loud, erratic pulse, but cinematic fluency evaporates after about 45 minutes. Even horror afficianados will likely tire at the insipidity.