A man learns that hard way that not all high school memories are pleasant in this thriller. Paul Preedy (Daniel Baldwin) is invited to a high school reunion, but figures someone is playing a trick on him when he discovers he's one of only three people asked to attend. However, Paul soon learns what's going on is no joke; his two fellow alumni are dead a few days later, both the victims of a killer who used a water torture on them before they died. Paul finds himself the key suspect in the police's investigation of the crimes, and Paul is forced to come to terms with a disturbing incident from his past that links him to the killer. Water Damage also stars Dean Stockwell, Leslie Hope, and Mimi Kuzyk.