The stars of a classic television series look back on old adventures while facing new intrigue in this made-for-TV comedy drama. Adam West and Burt Ward, best remembered for playing Batman and Robin on the hit show Batman in the 1960s, learn that someone intends to steal the original Batmobile from a charity event where they've agreed to appear. West and Ward set out to capture the ne'er-do-wells before the crime can occur, and as they investigate likely suspects, they recall the heyday of the Batman series and the massive impact it had on their lives. While Adam West and Burt Ward play themselves in the present-day sequences of Return to the Bat Cave, they're respectively played by Jack Brewer and Jason Marsden in the 1960s flashbacks.
~ Mark Deming, All Movie Guide