Somewhere inside of Pitch Perfect there exists the movie it wants to be. Buried beneath the scathing send-ups of the dreamer genre, there are actual dreamers. Ones we’re charged to root for — after all, we are hinged to their story about “making it to regionals,” or whatever — but that we can’t. Because the film itself refuses to do so. At once, it’s a celebration of the socially disbarred and a satire of all the sugar-coated entertainment that has been devoted to it… okay, mostly Glee. And while this marriage isn’t necessarily doomed, too often does Pitch Perfect find itself torn between asking us to root for its heroes and asking us to laugh at its victims (the same people). We can’t say for sure whether something was lost in translation from script to screen, or of Kay Cannon’s original screenplay was laden with the troubles we find on the screen, but we’re hoping that the upcoming sequel’s new director, actress Elizabeth Banks, can figure out her animal better than first installment helmer Jason Moore could.
In order to do so, she’ll have to know when the movie need to stop laughing at these people. And here’s a good indicator: if it is laughing at them for being fat or gay, you’ve probably taken a wrong turn.
The film offers glimpses of its potential — loner Anna Kendrick identifying Brittany Snow’s shared familiarity with David Guetta’s “Titanium” as awe-inspiring (one of the film’s better attempts at tackling a genre staple) — but undoes its own mission when it turns the trope battering in on its characters. Pitch Perfect sets up its underdog a capella clique as a group of eccentrics with whom we’re supposed to relate: genuine talents unappreciated due to weight, race, sexual orientation, and a laundry list of personality defects. But just when you think the movie is on their side, it jumps right on in, poking fun at Rebel Wilson’s character for her size and Ester Dean’s for her homosexuality. And one might spout the defense, “But these girls are making fun of themselves!” Well, that’s the problem. They think they have to.
Wilson’s breakout character goes by “Fat Amy,” underlining her self-assigned moniker with the rationale, “So twig b**ches like you [she’s talking to Anna Camp] don’t do it behind my back.” Therein lies the film’s defeat. It thinks that these girls have no shot at dignity, so they have to succumb to self-parody. This is not simply embracing a sense of humor about yourself (a valuable characteristic) but becoming the joke that everybody says you are because you don’t see any other choice. And Pitch Perfect doesn’t just limit this fate to “Fat Amy,” but to its excessively marginalized gay character, Cynthia Rose (Dean).
Universal via Everett Collection
The joke about Dean? The same joke that has been assigned to gay characters since before the days of Three’s Company, and that still, by some grace of ungodly ignorance, works its way into network television and blockbuster cinema today. Her sexual orientation is her punchline. For the length of Pitch Perfect, we’re offered “hints” that Cynthia Rose is attracted to women — the way she dresses and carries herself are brandished as lesbian stereotypes, and we even get a scene of her groping fellow a capella band member Stacie (Alexis Knapp) for good measure. And then, finally, concrete evidence: “When I broke up with my girlfriend…” followed by a de facto rimshot from Rebel Wilson.
Of course, Pitch Perfect was a hit, and this is owed to a very simple, very convenient allowance made by its story: the singing. Yes, these girls can sing. And when they get up on that stage at the end of the film and belt their heroic ballads, it’s as if the film is saying, “See? We were behind them all along!” But giving stars like Wilson and Rose solos doesn’t retroactively make Pitch Perfect‘s mean-spirited attitude about their identities “good natured ribbing.” We were still asked to look at Fat Amy as a fat girl first, swelling with laughter at her inability to run, her propensity for falling down, and — most riotous of all — the inscrutable idea that she might consider herself sexy. You can endorse this material all you like with defenses that Fat Amy and Wilson herself were on board with the gags, but the simple fact that the one overweight young woman in this movie feels no other course than to dominate her screen time with fat jokes is unforgivable. Some would call it wise advice to garnish an embarrassing faux-pas with some self-effacing humor; this is not how heavy people should made to be felt about the way they look.
In earnest, there’s optimism attached to Banks’ ascension into the director’s chair. Although she has never handled a feature on her own, her comic sensibilities as an actress, and as a woman, might be more conducive to a little bit of respect for the young ladies at the center of this story. We can hope, anyway — with a wealth of talent in stars like Kendrick, Wilson, Dean, Camp, Snow, and the rest, and in a writer like Cannon, there’s too much good to let the end product wind up so misguided.