Reynolds topped the Fitness magazine countdown with 14 per cent of the vote, while Gosling was just one per cent behind him.
Taylor Lautner and Bradley Cooper tied for third place with 10 per cent each.
The poll also revealed that 38 per cent of the women asked to name the celebrity they'd consider having an affair with confessed they would cheat if given a free pass.
In a related survey, Reynolds' The Proposal co-star Sandra Bullock was the clear winner in a Classiest Composure poll, compiled to find the Hollywood wives who have best survived a cheating scandal.
Bullock, who dumped husband Jesse James after learning he had been unfaithful, scored 44 per cent of the vote. Arnold Schwarzenegger's estranged wife Maria Shriver came in a distant second with 13 per cent.