No matter what Pettyfer's reputation may be off-screen, you have to admit the guy has some serious magnetism on-screen. Case in point: his recent turn as a boy turned bad in the male stripper dramedy 'Magic Mike.' So not only is Pettyfer, like Finnick, a guy you have conflicting feelings for, but he's the right age and looks like the flirt-turned-foe we had in our minds. Runners-up: Taylor Kitsch, Garrett Hedlund, Armie Hammer, Ryan Kwanten.
