Emma is always dressed adorably, but there’s always one piece that’s just a little off. The nautical elements and red, white and blue combo is pitch perfect but that telephone pin is just a little old lady for our tastes. Grade: B+
Blaine is rocking his adorable sweater, with a nice little pop of red at the collar and sleeves. That hat could be a little much, but the trend is hot and he carries it. Grade: A
Alright, we know this was a bit of a costume for his West Side Story audition, but he looks kinda cute right? It’s simple, yet chic with a tad of retro flavor and we love it. Grade: A
Now this is how you dress a girl who can sing like Mercedes. No more of that gaudy flash she donned for the past two seasons, this grown-up wrap dress is sophisticate and absolutely beautiful. The hair could use a little help though. Grade: A-
Finn usually looks like he got dressed in the dark, like a typical teenage boy, but when he got dressed up for his father’s wedding he actually looked like a well-dressed young man – even if the suit is a little baggy. Grade: B-
Kurt’s usually adventurous, but he often fails to adhere to Coco Chanel’s rule: always take off the last accessory you put on. Kurt, you should have taken off that awful skull scarf; it ruins the cute military shirt/plaid pants thing you’ve got going on. Grade: C
These outfits still perplex me. Shiny, baby teal satin with rhinestones, leggings and combat boots? Sometimes the pretty/ugly thing works, but these getups are just plain ugly. Grade: F
We know it’s hard to find the perfect little black dress, but this one isn’t it. All those ruffled details dwarf Santana’s great figure, not to mention the dress is about as much fun as afternoon tea at grandma’s. Grade: D+
There are so many things wrong here. From the placement of that bow on her skirt to the monochrome quality of the outfit to the fact that it makes Rachel look like she’s about six years old, this outfit deserves detention. Grade: D-
Now this is more like it. A cute little frock with white and red polka dots and a pop of color from the maroon stockings are a good way to keep Rachel’s cutesy aesthetic without making her look like an American Girl doll. Grade: A
Santana’s looking a little boring so let’s focus on Britt. It’s playful and colorful, but the knee highs with high heels is just a little too Playboy Mansion for a high school kid. Grade: C+
Usually, Quinn is one of the best dressed ladies on Glee, but when she dyed her hair pink she started dressing like a girl trying to get her parents’ attention…in a bad 80s movie. Grade: D
The Mohawk comb-over has got to go, but Puck’s got the slightly-tailored, slightly rugged look down. It sure beats the tight t-shirt, possibly-eyelinered look he rocked last season. Grade: B+
Which episode is this photo from? Who cares – Schue wears the same thing every week. Yes, he looks pretty good in it, but there are other wardrobe choices, you know. Minus points for lack of creativity. Grade: B-
