Lilly and the team re-open the 1973 case of a murdered football player after new evidence surfaces that shows that he may have been killed earlier than originally thought. As they investigate they also learn that a steroid cover-up might have been involved.
The team reopens an investigation of a teacher's death when one of her former students comes forward with information leading them to believe that it wasn't a carjacking after all.
Rush and the team investigate the 1964 murder case of a young white woman who, under the guise of selling Tupperware, secretly traveled in a mixed group to Mississippi during Freedom Summer to bring supplies and help with the Freedom schools.
Lilly and the team investigate the 1978 case of the death of a teenaged roller-skater who was found in a ravine when her friend at the time comes forward with new information. Meanwhile, Miller goes out on a blind date.
Rush and the team investigate the case of a young Marine who was found dead after being AWOL on his last night of shore leave. They discover that, on that night, he was trying to defend a fellow soldier.
Lilly and the team investigate the 1981 case of a missing single mother after her body is found in the trunk of a car, and soon discover that many of her co-workers at a seedy car dealership resented her.
Lilly and the team reopen the 1969 case of a murdered 12-year-old boy after a toy rocket bearing his name is given to the retired cop who worked on the case and was never able to let it go.
Lilly and the team reopen the 1989 murder case of a young Russian opera singer who defected with her family before the Berlin Wall came down. Vera remembers the case well as he was a rookie at the police station where they sought political asylum.
Lilly and the team re-open the 1953 case of a pin up girl when a fan's crime scene photo provides new and vital evidence in the case.
Rush and the team reopen the 2005 murder case of a young African-American politician who vowed to rid the lower-class neighborhood he grew up in of drug dealers who prey on young kids.