In a flash forward, we see Hurley getting arrested after seeing someone/something in a store and racing away in his car. It appears he is hallucinating again.
In a flashback, we see rescuer Daniel upset while watching footage of underwater wreckage of Flight 815. Back on the island, he tells Jack and Kate that he's there to rescue them, but needs to use their phone, in private, to talk to the people on his chopper.
As the episode begins, Sayid investigates Naomi's dead body and discovers an inscribed bracelet. He makes a deal with Lapidus that he will return Charlotte to safety in exchange for a flight to the boat.
Locke asks Ben, who he is holding hostage, for information. Ben mocks John for his inability to know what to do next. Sawyer wants Kate to stay with him in the others village, but she refuses.
Lapidus, Sayid, and Desmond are flying in the helicopter through some bad weather when Desmond flashes to a time when he was in military boot camp. He thinks his time in the helicopter was a dream.
In a flashback to when Juliet was first brought to the island, she meets with a therapist named Harper. She leaves the therapist's office and meets Ben, who presents her with a beautiful house.
On the freighter, Regina nervously guards Sayid and Desmond who are locked in a room. Lapidus brings them some lima beans, but doesn't let them speak to the captain.
Locke holds a meeting for everyone in the barracks including Ben and Miles. Miles explains that his people are there for Ben. Ben says that once they capture him, they will kill everyone on the island.
Jack is taking pills for a stomach-ache when a body washes up on shore at the beach with his throat slit. Faraday confirms that it is the doctor from the freighter.
In a flash forward, we see Jack and Kate living together with Aaron. On the island, Miles hears ghost whispers and discovers Danielle and Karl's dead bodies in a shallow grave while walking through the jungle with Sawyer, Kate and Aaron.
IN a flashback to the 50's, a teenage girl named Emily runs outside to meet her older boyfriend and is hit by a speeding car. At the hospital, Emily tells the doctors she is pregnant and gives birth to a boy she names John.
In a flash forward, we see the Oceanic Six being flown from the island to the mainland. Jack prepares everyone to lie to their families and the press about the real story behind their survival.
In a flash forward, we see a continuation of the conversation Jack and Kate had in the final episode of season 3 outside the airport. Kate is angry at Jack for saying they have to go back to the island.
In a flash forward, Sayid kills a man outside of Hurley's mental hospital. He tells Hurley that he has to take him someplace safe. Hurley does not want to go, until he hears that Jeremy Bentham was murdered.