With everyone's lives turned upside down now that her psychic abilities are public, Allison begins having disturbing dreams about a young boy snatched from a toy store while shopping with his dad. Unable to turn to Devalos or Scanlon for help, Allison calls Ameritips, a company hired by the missing boy's family, and strikes an unusual deal with their intriguing investigator Cynthia Keener.
Allison is distressed by a terrible family prediction while attempting to help Ameritips investigator Cynthia Keener find a missing local teenage girl. Meanwhile, after being asked out to an unchaperoned concert, Ariel's dreams transport her to her mother's high school class in the 80s.
Joe's search for a new job takes an unexpected turn when a prospective employer asks him and Allison to a party at his home, confiding that his wife was hoping to meet Phoenix's reported psychic. Allison reluctantly agrees, and begins to see how her recent dreams of Paris tie to the later disappearance of their host's soon-to-be wed daughter.
Allison completely loses her hearing when a wealthy, young deaf girl is kidnapped, so Joe steps in to assist with her and investigator Cynthia Keener's actions on behalf of the parents.
Allison's long-standing nemesis, defense attorney Larry Watt, decides to use her powers to his advantage by hiring her as a consultant. Unfortunately, Allison's dreams tell her that his client is guilty of killing his wife. Meanwhile, Devalos and Ariel individually start new ventures.
Allison does her best to support Devalos' bid to reclaim the D.A.'s office, as her visions place his strongest political supporter and longtime friend Senator Jed Garrity in the center of a horrific conspiracy. Meanwhile, Bridgette has a dream about a persistent creditor, calling from a world away.
When Joe's mom, Marjorie Dubois, abruptly arrives for a visit, Allison frets about seeing her mother-in-law for the first time since her psychic abilities were publicly revealed, until she learns the real reason for the trip. Meanwhile, as Ameritips investigator Cynthia Keener attempts to nudge Allison's dreams towards open cases, Ariel forsees the death of a classmate's mother.
While struggling to keep Marjorie's secret from Joe, Allison attempts to find the link between her dreams of a dentist's violent assault on a prostitute she's investigating with Cynthia, Devalos' arson-related murder case, and Ariel's prediction of the death of her classmate's mom.
While working with Cynthia to find a missing local girl, Allison dreams about the kidnapping of another young woman and learns that Cynthia's daughter Suzie has been missing for nearly 10 years. Meanwhile, Bridgette's science class project sparks Joe's imagination -- and tests his relationship with Allison.
Allison and Cynthia Keener's investigation into the decade-old kidnapping, imprisonment and murder of Cynthia's daughter Suzie comes to a shocking, brutal conclusion. Meanwhile, Bridgette predicts good fortune for Joe, who's looking into funding for his new invention.
Allison and Scanlon team up to track down a dangerous femme fatale following the savage murders of two young men. Meanwhile, as the campaign for local D.A. revs up, Allison gets the feeling that someone close to Devalos is plotting against him.
Venture capitalist Meghan Doyle likes what she sees when Joe makes a presentation on his new solar power-based invention to her investment firm. She makes him a personal offer to fund his invention, but she would hold the controlling share of the business. Meanwhile, FBI profiler Agent Edward Cooper tries to convince Allison he's back in Phoenix to track down -- not murder -- another serial killer, but her dreams tell her a different story.
Allison struggles to see the connection between several recent "accidental" deaths after experiencing visions of Scanlon and girlfriend Lynn DiNovi's friend dying in a home mishap and a scary trip to the hospital herself. Meanwhile, Joe must find a cheap, inventive answer to Marie's need for glasses after she tricks the optometrist.
When Allison's old automobile sputters and dies, Joe surprises her with an immaculate used car, after being tipped off to a great deal. Unfortunately, the Dubois' discover that the car is at the center of a horrific, unsolved crime. Meanwhile, Allison meets Joe's new business partner Meghan Doyle for the first time and begins to feel uneasy about the attractive venture capitalist.
Allison's visions help Scanlon get a lead on the person responsible for a meticulous, brutal hit on a wealthy local drug dealer, but both are confused when her dreams of a charming killer direct them to Joey Carmichael, a severely impaired man with a bullet lodged in his brain. Meanwhile, an awkward moment between venture capitalist Meghan Doyle and Joe could tear their business partnership apart.
In the season finale, Allison attempts to convince a young couple that their "dream home" isn't haunted. What Allison didn't expect to ensue, was misery and murder. Meanwhile, Joe finds out the truth behind Meghan's plans for his invention, and their joint venture. Then, the D.A's race takes a turn when Tom Van Dyke calls Devalos in for a meeting.