Katie Fox tries to balance her day job as a divorce lawyer and her recreational work fixing people up. She falls under the microscope when a wedding couple outs her matchmaker skills to a newspaper. She turns her attentions towards a slightly wallflower doctor and his big dog.
Kate tries to help a struggling musician find out whether his ex-girlfriend's child is his. Kate feels betrayed by Laurel when she finds out she's hording good men. Kate's friends Peter and Gabby come to her to take care of their divorce.
Kate handles a divorce case wherein her client admits to sleeping with the nanny. On the matchmaking side, a high school rival comes to Kate for some of her matchmaking magic.
Kate tries to help an engaged couple overcome their fear of committing to each other by setting them up on dates. Kate benefits from couples therapy when her ex re-enters her life.
Kate has to shift her responsibilities from bridesmaid to legal representative when her friend Gabrielle's fiancee calls off their wedding. To make matters worse, Gabrielle bans Kate from a relationship with a guy she met at the bridal shower.
Kate tries to step back a bit from her matchmaking as she's confronted as a love addict, but when one of her couples hits a rough patch, her need to get involved kicks in. In the legal side of her life, Kate has to take on Jerry's ex-girlfriend.
Kate's attempt at hosting a Thanksgiving dinner doesn't go as swimmingly as she hoped. Also, Kate learns that the relationship between Amy and Michael is not as ideal as it appeared to be on the surface.
Kate has her hands full between trying to find a match for a client's lesbian daughter and being tricked by a con artist who uses successful women to support himself.
Michael's ex-girlfriend makes things difficult for Kate's precarious balance of work and social life. In the legal realm, Kate takes on a tv producer whose show led to a couple's divorce. When the judge seeks Kate's matchmaking magic, Kate finds her success in one area tied tightly to the other.
Serena Lockner returns to Kate's life, seeking her help in an adoption. Kate must also keep her relationship with Michael secret from her client Lauren as Lauren is divorcing Michael. Victoria's life gets interesting when she spends time as a mall elf.
An Indian woman turns to Kate's matchmaking in an effort to avoid an arranged marriage. In court, Lauren and Michael's divorce begins.