Skyler comes to the bookstore looking for a self-help book to explain why she always falls for the wrong guy. Gavin gets Skyler to pretend to be his girlfriend in order to make his ex-wife jealous.
Gavin finds the employee of his dreams and Skyler tries to find a way to compete.
Gavin decides that, after making fun of Skyler for being a groupie, he is also one in a different arena.
Gavin tells Stuart that he had a sex dream about Skyler and Stuart feels betrayed. Skyler reveals that she had a sex dream about Harold. Katrina sells peanut butter balls to fund her wisdom teeth removal.
Gavin finds himself buddying up to Skyler's ex-boyfriend when he goes to retrieve Skyler's grandfather's watch. After Gavin fails, Stuart attempts to liberate the watch with the same result. Skyler tries to keep her mind off things by joining Katrina's knitting group. Though the group initially rejects her, they rush to her side when she confronts Eddie.