The women are given five minutes to prepare to meet Charlie O'Connell, the new bachelor for the first time. Twelve women move on.
Two women who are chosen as the most compatible with Charlie are given the first individual dates. Charlie must decide to either give them a rose during the date or have them leave immediately without returning to the house. Three women are sent home.
Charlie takes one bachelorette to an art gallery, one skating in Central Park, and the rest go bowling with him. One bachelorette leaves without a rose.
The women go on another round of individual and group dates. Charlie must eliminate two women.
The final four women take Charlie to visit their parents and hometowns. One women is sent home.
The three remaining women go on exotic overnight dates with Charlie in Aruba. After the rose ceremony, only Sarah and Krisily remain.
Charlie brings Sarah and Krisily home to meet her parents. At the final rose ceremony, Charlie chooses Sarah.