Matt moves into his Malibu bachelor pad and prepares for the night of his life -- a fabulous party with 25 beautiful American bachelorettes. As the women arrive and discover that Matt is British, they are knocked off their feet by his handsome good looks, his sexy accent and his British sense of humor. At the end of the night, ten women are sent home.
The women are split into two groups for dates. The first group perform in a fashion show for Matt. Ashley is given a rose and the first kiss. The second group goes with Matt to Vegas. Chelsea is given a rose. Erin H., Carri, and Michelle P. are sent home.
Holly gets a one-on-one date with Matt at a private movie screening. At the end of the date, she receives a rose. Then, Matt takes a group of girls on a group date to play rugby with him. While there, he gives Robyn a rose. After that, he has a one-on-one date with Shayne where he gives her a rose. At the rose ceremony, three women are sent home - Erin S., Amy, and Kristine.
Matt takes Ashlee, Noelle, Shayne, Robin, Kelly and Chelsea on a group date for tennis and high tea. At the end of the date, he gives Chelsea a rose. Then, he has a one-on-one date with Amanda at a 1950's diner and ends up giving her a rose as well. Holly and Marshana are chosen for a two-on-one date in which Marshana is given a rose and Holly is sent home. At the rose ceremony, Ashlee and Kelly are sent home as well.
Matt and the ladies go on a trip to Sun Valley, Idaho. Matt takes Chelsea on a one-on-one date where Chelsea tries to show him her romantic side. Then, Matt has a group date on the slopes for skiing and snowboarding. Finally, he chooses to take Noelle on a one-on-one date for ice skating. At the rose ceremony, he sends Marshana and Robin home.
The stakes are high for Matt as he leaves his Malibu home for an exciting, emotionally-charged journey across the country to visit the final four women's hometowns and ends up being the target of an elaborate prank by Amanda where she hires actors to play her parents. At the rose ceremony, her sends home Noelle. Chelsea, Shayne, and Amanda are left as the final three.
Matt takes Shayne, Amanda, and Chelsea to Barbados for romantic and exotic overnight dates. At the rose ceremony, he sends Amanda home.
The women who Matt sent home come back to talk about their experiences, answer questions, and ask Matt a few questions of their own.
Matt faces an excruciating decision between Chelsea and Shayne, and ultimately chooses to propose to Shayne, who accepts.