In the small town of Poland, NH three brothers face family and career challenges. Dottie wants to buy the old movie theater and goes to her husband Hank's nemesis, Scott Haggis for funding.
Dottie's feelings are hurt when Hank does not show support; Hank threatens Sharon Ropers to keep her affair with Garrett quiet; Auditions for the Easter pageant begin.
When Waylon sells ice cream to some children and elderly woman shoots him with a paintball gun; Dottie tells Julie that a young banker has a crush on her.
When the new minister of the town reveals that he is homosexual, the Shaw brothers argue over whether they should support him; Dottie has new that could tear apart the family.
A teenage girl disappears and Hank investigates while Waylon uses a crime-sniffing chihuahua to find her; The women of Poland begin to wonder about their children's sex lives.