Holy Nostalgia! Kelly Clarkson Repeats “Natural Woman” ‘Idol’ Performance 10 Years Later

Kelly Clarkson Sings Natural Woman

Back in 2002, under-the-radar American Idol contestant Kelly Clarkson suddenly found herself in front-runner status after belting a note only heard by dogs and Mariah Carey during her Top 8 performance of Aretha Franklin’s “(You Make Me Feel Like) A Natural Woman.”

RELATED: Best and Worst Performances of Grammys 2013

And just over 10 years later, the pop star returned to the hit during the 2013 Grammys, giving Idol fans a nostalgic trip back to the days when chunky highlights and love for Justin Guarini reigned supreme. (And we should enjoy the nostalgia while it lasts — what are the chances the singer will ever give a rousing repeat performance of “A Moment Like This” again?) 

But the question becomes: In the battle between Grammy-winning Clarkson and bowler hat-topped Clarkson, which came out on top?  

Trick question: We do. 

Follow Kate on Twitter @HWKateWard

[Image Credit: Kevork Djansezian/Getty Images]

From Our Partners:

Hottest Celebrity Twitpics40 Hottest Celeb Twitpics of the Month (Vh1)

Sports Illustrated Kate Upton‘Sports Illustrated’ Swimsuit Issue: A Visual History (Celebuzz)